What’s the value of a tree? To answer this question, the first reaction is to consider how many stamps or pieces of IKEA furniture can be made with it. But this way, we’re not counting the oxygen it creates or its role in an ecosystem, and, well, that’s the problem.
In today’s economic and financial systems, nature’s positive and negative externalities are not adequately accounted for: the negative externalities of degraded or lost ecosystems, such as greater flood risk or more severe wildfires, are not recognized, and likewise, positive contributions related to nature’s production and infrastructure are completely left out when considering its value.
Because of this oversight, financial markets and societies value nature’s destruction over its conservation: for every US dollar invested in protecting nature, US $30 is spent destroying it. To meet global biodiversity, climate and land restoration targets, annual public and private funding for nature-based solutions—actions that protect and restore ecosystems while benefiting people—must increase 2.5 times, from US $220 billion to US $571 billion by 2030, equivalent to 0.5% of global GDP.
To promote nature-positive investments and accurately value nature, one company, the Intrinsic Exchange Group (IEG), in partnership with the New York Stock Exchange, has developed a new financial tool: Natural Asset Companies (NACs).
Natural assets are assets and resources of the environment. They are divided into 6 categories: mineral and energy resources, land, soil resources, timber resources, aquatic resources, water resources, and other biological resources.
NACs are corporations that hold the rights to the value of these assets and the ecosystem services they produce. Their objective is to maximise the ecological performance of the geographical area under their management. More concretely, NACs incorporate the value of nature into the enterprise value of a company mandated to protect and grow its natural assets. Investors can then purchase shares of the company and trade them. The growth of natural assets, which includes the quality of ecosystem services produced, therefore translates into financial growth for the company and the shareholders.
A question that may arise regards the valuation of these assets.
Natural assets are valued with a holistic framework that includes their intrinsic value, the production value of ecosystem services and option value. The intrinsic value is made up of the existence value of natural assets (the value they hold for people simply knowing of the continued existence of ecosystems and species) and their bequest value, meaning the value of ecosystems being available for future generations. The benefits produced by nature, which support the global economy and are estimated at US $125 trillion annually, are accounted for by the production value of ecosystem services. Finally, option value takes into consideration the potential for monetization of ecosystem services in the future.
A NAC is an equity capital structure that fully values natural capital, but it also delivers financial returns. It does so by providing a market rate of return on investment through 4 mechanisms:
- Asset appreciation, which encompasses growth in the production of ecosystem services, as well as in the quality of underlying natural assets, thanks to active management.
- Cash flow generation, the income derived from sales of ecosystem services, contracts or sustainable operations (such as the sale of carbon credits).
- Market acceptance, meaning growing recognition and acceptance of the NACs’ asset valuations in the market.
- Investor participation: with rising confidence in NACs’ long-term value, ease of trading, and greater liquidity, there’s an increased capital inflow from investors. It builds a larger pool of interested buyers who support share prices and make shares easier to trade.
One may wonder why NACs aren’t more widespread if they constitute such an accurate response to financial markets’ inability to value nature. While being a very hopeful and efficient tool, NACs still face a lot of challenges which prevent them from being widely used.
First, the valuation of ecosystem services continues to be very complex, context-dependent and often intangible, which raises concerns about transparency and comparability across NACs from different regions and ecosystems.
A second challenge is raised by the fear that ownership of the land will pass to actors far away from it, which disempowers neighboring communities.
Finally, there’s also a fear of greenwashing legitimized by 14 incidents in 2024.
IEG tries to respond to these concerns, especially to the first one, by requiring that NACs’ reporting include two components. One is standard financial reporting, which includes goods and services produced by NACs that generate cash flows, using US Generally Accepted Accounting Principles as well as International Reporting Standards. The second is an Ecological Performance Report, which measures the condition and economic value of natural assets possessed by NACs as well as their production of ecosystem services, and is prepared in accordance with Natural Capital Accounting Principles (a common tool to measure the changes in the stock and condition of natural capital, based on the United Nations’ new statistical framework).
If NACs manage to overcome these challenges, they could represent a great opportunity to shift financing from nature-negative activities to nature-based solutions and get us closer to bridging the financing gap.
Written by Auxane Coin
Bibliography